Québec Egg Sauce for Salmon Pie
A wedge of salmon pie needs just enough sauce to moisten the fish and potatoes while the edge of the crust stays crisp. I make this Québec egg sauce with milk, a pale butter roux and chopped hard-boiled eggs. It pours easily off the ladle, with soft pieces of egg in every spoonful.

What to look for in the saucepan
Pull a salmon and potato pie from the oven and look at the cut face of a slice. There is a broad side of flaky fish and potato that will catch the sauce, and a narrow rim of pastry worth protecting. That tells you how thick to make the sauce. It should travel down the cut side when you tilt the plate slightly. A sauce thick enough to stand in a mound will pull the filling apart as you try to spread it.
The starting point is a white sauce made with a roux. Eggs bring quite a bit of body once you add them, particularly if some yolk crumbles into the milk. Stop reducing while the plain sauce still seems a touch loose. Compare it with the thicker coating on a cauliflower gratin. Here the ladle has to lift some egg and enough liquid to carry it all the way to the plate.
Cook and cut the eggs
Choose a saucepan just wide enough to hold the three eggs in a single layer. Cover them with cold water by about an inch, bring the water to a boil, cover the pan and take it off the burner. Give large eggs eleven minutes in the covered water. Have a bowl of ice water waiting. Lift the eggs straight into it and leave them until they feel cool enough to peel comfortably. Meanwhile use a second pan to start the sauce.

Crack the shells gently and start peeling at the wide end, where a little air pocket often gives your thumb room to work. Rinse away shell fragments and pat the eggs dry. Cut each into quarters lengthwise and slice across into rough pieces about a third of an inch wide. Use the same light touch you would for an avocado and boiled egg salad. Scrape up the loose yolk too. A few crumbs give the milk a warmer colour without turning the sauce into egg paste.
Build the sauce in the pan
Melt the butter over medium-low heat in a pan with room to whisk. As soon as it is liquid, sprinkle in the flour and stir into the corners. Cook for about ninety seconds. The paste should bubble quietly and smell a little like warm biscuit dough. Keep it pale. If the butter is already turning brown before you add the flour, take the pan off the burner for a moment. Brown butter tastes wonderful on fish but will give this particular sauce a different flavour and colour.

For six servings, draw the ladle along the bottom of the pan before lifting each portion. The heavier pieces of white can settle while the pie is being cut. A gentle sweep brings them back into the sauce and gives the first and last slices much the same balance of egg and milk.
Add the milk in four pours. The first splash will give you a thick paste. Whisk it smooth against the bottom before adding more milk. With each addition there is less resistance. When the last of the milk is in, switch occasionally from the whisk to a flat-edged spoon. Run it around the base where the curved wires miss. Watch for the first slow bubbles across the surface, then cook gently for three minutes, stirring. Taste a little on a clean spoon. It should taste of milk and butter, with no chalky flour taste.
Season lightly before the eggs go in. Salted fish or a well-seasoned potato filling may need very little extra salt on the plate. Fold the chopped eggs into the milk with a spoon, just long enough to warm them through. Put the whisk away at this stage. Stirring with it breaks up the whites and disperses every bit of yolk. For other ways of pairing fish with sauce, look at the salmon recipe collection. Here I keep the seasoning quiet enough to let the salmon in the pie come through.
Make ahead and substitutions

For a dinner with several dishes, make the plain white sauce a day ahead and chill it promptly in a shallow covered container. Keep the cooked eggs refrigerated separately. As you warm the sauce over gentle heat, whisk in milk a spoonful at a time until it runs off the spoon again. Add the chopped eggs only once the base is smooth. If you plan an entire menu of Québec family classics, that leaves the last few minutes free for carving the pie and warming the plates.
Lactose-free dairy milk works in the same amount. Salted butter also works if you hold back the added salt until the end. Black pepper leaves visible specks and gives a slightly livelier finish than white pepper. If you have extra asparagus, steam it separately and spoon a little egg sauce over the spears at the table. For a dish that can wait in the oven, use the asparagus gratin instead. The amount of sauce and the way it is finished are designed for baking.
Questions from the kitchen
How do I rescue a lumpy sauce?
If the eggs are still on the board, lift the pan off the heat and whisk firmly, then pass the sauce through a fine sieve if needed. Return it to gentle heat and taste before adding the eggs. Once the pieces are in, avoid blending the whole pan. Lift the egg pieces out with a slotted spoon if you need to smooth the base. A completely smooth texture suits cream of asparagus soup, but recognizable pieces of white and yolk give this sauce its character.
What else can I serve it with?
Spoon it over a plain baked fish fillet or a split baked potato. Choose a lightly seasoned fish from these seafood dinner ideas so the milk and egg stay distinct. With a full pie supper, I serve one ladle alongside each slice and pass the rest separately. If you enjoy the same combination of soft filling and a lightly browned exterior, the savory stuffed crêpes offer another way to build that kind of meal.
Serving suggestions and related recipes
Cut the salmon and potato pie before bringing out the sauce so every piece retains a clean crust edge. If you are planning a first course, a small cup of cream of asparagus soup can be served while the pie settles.

Québec Egg Sauce for Salmon Pie
Ingredients
- 3 large eggs
- 2 tbsp plus ½ tsp unsalted butter
- ¼ cup all-purpose flour spooned and levelled
- 1â…ž cups milk
- ⅜ tsp fine salt or to taste
- White pepper to taste
Instructions
- Cover eggs with cold water, bring to a boil, cover, remove from heat and wait 11 minutes. Ice, peel and chop.
- Melt butter and cook the flour in it for 90 seconds, stirring.

- Whisk in the milk in four additions. Simmer gently for 3 minutes, stirring.
- Season, fold in the eggs, warm gently and serve.






