Delmonico Potatoes with Sharp Cheddar and Buttered Crumbs
Delmonico potatoes are diced potatoes baked in a creamy sauce with a browned topping. For this version I use sharp cheddar in two places, melted into the milk sauce and scattered under a light breadcrumb crust. Parboiling the cubes first gives them a head start so the centre is tender by the time the crumbs are golden.

Cut for a spoon rather than a stack
Peel the potatoes and trim away eyes or dark patches. Cut a small flat face on the first potato so it sits steadily on the board. Slice it into slabs about five-eighths of an inch thick, cut the slabs into strips and turn the strips across the blade to make cubes. Repeat with the rest. Aim for pieces close enough in size to soften at the same pace. Very thin scraps can go into another pot of soup. A few smaller bits in the gratin are fine, but a handful of tiny pieces will break down while the large cubes are still firm.
Yellow potatoes are a good choice because a cooked cube still has corners you can see when you lift a spoonful. The shape distinguishes this dish from gratin dauphinois, built from overlapping slices. It also changes how the sauce works. Instead of running between sheets of potato, the cheddar sauce must coat several faces of each cube and fill little gaps in the dish. Use a fairly shallow, buttered two-quart baking dish. A deep bowl makes it hard to heat the middle without overbrowning the top.
Parboil and let the steam escape
Bring a pot of salted water to a boil, add the cubes and lower the heat once the water comes back to a simmer. Start checking after six minutes. A knife should go through the outside easily and meet some resistance in the centre. Lift one cube onto a plate and cut it in half to see how far the heat has travelled. The edges should hold when moved with a spoon. Full tenderness at this stage is useful for mash, but those cubes may fall apart as you fold them into sauce and bake them again.
Drain after about six to nine minutes and spread the potatoes in the colander so the steam can escape. Give the colander a gentle shake to release trapped water. Water caught between the cubes thins the sauce even if it looked right in the pan. The same care with draining helps in a cauliflower and potato gratin. While the potatoes steam dry, grate the cheese and divide it into two piles. The larger pile goes into the sauce and the smaller one goes onto the surface.
Make the cheddar sauce without boiling the cheese
Melt 25 g (about 1¾ tbsp) of butter in a saucepan over medium-low heat. Set aside 15 g (about 1 tbsp) for the crumbs. Stir the flour into the melted butter and cook for a minute. The paste should bubble lightly without taking much colour. Add the milk gradually, beating each addition smooth with a whisk before pouring more. Reach into the corners where flour paste can cling untouched. Once all the milk is in, let the sauce simmer gently for three minutes, stirring. This is the same basic roux technique used for white sauce.

Take the saucepan off the burner before adding the larger pile of cheddar and the paprika. Stir until smooth and taste with a small piece of potato before adding salt. A sharp cheddar contributes more seasoning than a mild young cheese. If it does not melt at once, wait a few seconds and stir again in the residual heat. Boiling the sauce hard after the cheese goes in can leave little oily spots at the surface. It should pour in a broad ribbon, thick enough to coat a cube yet loose enough to settle between pieces.
Fold, top and bake until the centre bubbles
Fold the potatoes into the sauce with a broad spoon, lifting from the bottom so the edges remain intact. Tip the mixture into the prepared baking dish and ease it toward the corners. Scatter the remaining cheddar evenly. Melt the reserved butter and rub it through the crumbs so there are no wet clumps. Sprinkle them on loosely. A thin crumb layer gives you a little crunch in each serving, as on a cauliflower gratin. Packing it down makes a lid that breaks off in one piece when you serve.

Bake at 375°F for thirty to thirty-five minutes. Look for bubbling nearer the middle as well as at the rim and check a potato in the centre with a thin knife. The blade should pass through without a firm spot. If the crumbs are golden before the centre is tender, cover loosely and keep baking. Let the dish settle for a few minutes before serving. It makes a good side for steak au poivre or maple roast chicken. Keep the meat juices beside the gratin so the crumb topping stays dry.
Make ahead and substitutions

For a dinner the next day, assemble the potatoes and sauce in the baking dish, cool promptly and refrigerate. Keep the finishing cheese and crumbs separate and add them just before baking. A cold dish takes longer to heat than a freshly assembled one. Allow extra time and check the middle rather than relying on the colour of the top. If you would prefer a potato side that cooks in broth, pommes boulangères give a tender layered dish without the cheese sauce.
Gruyère can replace cheddar by weight and gives a nuttier flavour. A mix of the two works if you have small pieces to finish. Use dry unseasoned crumbs so garlic, salt and herbs from a commercial coating do not overwhelm the cheese. For a full meal baked in one dish, beef and potato gratin includes meat and is balanced around it. Adding cooked beef directly to this recipe without adjusting the sauce can leave the middle dry.

Questions about the sauce and potatoes
Why did my sauce disappear into the dish?
Check how finely the potatoes were cut and whether they were already fully tender before assembly. A lot of broken potato can bind nearly all the sauce and turn the middle into a dense mash. Next time, keep the dice even, drain thoroughly and fold gently. Other potato side dishes deliberately use mashed potato, but here the point is to lift distinct cubes coated with cheese.
How do I brown a pale topping?
If the potatoes are done but the crumbs are pale, a brief finish under the broiler works in a broiler-safe dish. Stay close and remove it as soon as the crumbs turn gold. For a softer topping, leave the pan on the middle rack and skip that step. A vegetable dish such as asparagus gratin offers a similar creamy finish when you want to build the menu around spring vegetables instead.
Serving suggestions and related recipes
Bring the casserole to the table while the steak au poivre rests. With maple roast chicken, use a slotted spoon for the potatoes so the roasting juices and cheddar sauce each keep their place.

Delmonico Potatoes with Sharp Cheddar and Buttered Crumbs
Ingredients
- 1 lb 14 oz yellow potatoes peeled
- 40 g unsalted butter divided (25 g for the sauce and 15 g for the crumbs), plus extra for the dish
- 3 tbsp all-purpose flour
- 1½ cups plus 1 tbsp milk
- 5 oz sharp cheddar grated and divided
- 1 oz fine dry breadcrumbs
- ⅜ tsp paprika
- Fine salt to taste
Instructions
- Heat oven to 375°F and butter a shallow 2-quart dish. Cut potatoes into ⅝-inch cubes. Simmer in salted water 6 to 9 minutes until edges soften. Drain and steam dry.
- Melt 25 g (about 1¾ tbsp) butter. Cook flour in it for 1 minute. Gradually whisk in milk and simmer 3 minutes.
- Off heat, melt 3½ oz cheddar into sauce and add paprika. Taste for salt. Fold in potatoes and transfer to dish.

- Top with remaining cheddar. Mix crumbs with remaining 15 g of melted butter and scatter over cheese. Bake 30 to 35 minutes until bubbling and tender at the centre.







Last chance for our paring knives.