9 Steak Sauces and Butters for Grilled or Pan-Seared Steak

A steak sauce should fit both the meat and the way you are cooking. For a grilled steak, compound butter prepared ahead makes serving straightforward. For a skillet steak, Dijon sauce uses the browned bits in the pan. Mushrooms, red wine and Roquefort each take a dinner in a different direction.

These nine sauces and finishing butters offer distinct flavors and methods. Use the comparison to choose a style and plan the preparation. Pairings are serving suggestions; follow each full recipe for ingredient quantities and cooking steps.

Compare steak sauces and finishing butters

These times cover the sauce or butter, not cooking the steak. Compound butters need refrigerator time in addition to mixing time.

Compound butters to prepare ahead

Montreal steak butter

This compound butter brings cracked pepper, coriander and garlic to the steak. Mix and shape it before cooking the meat so the log has time to firm up for slicing.

1

Montreal Steak Butter: Easy Compound Butter

This Montreal steak butter is a compound butter seasoned with cracked pepper, garlic, coriander, mustard, herbs and just enough salt to echo Montreal steak seasoning without burying the flavour of the beef. Slice a cold coin over a hot steak and it melts into a quick sauce as the meat rests.

Discover this recipe

Maître d’hôtel butter

Lemon and parsley give this butter a fresher profile than the Montreal seasoning blend. Mix it, shape it and chill it, then let a slice melt over the hot steak.

2

Beurre Maître d’Hôtel (Steakhouse Herb Butter) — The Classic French Finishing Butter

Beurre maître d’hôtel is a classic French compound butter made with butter, lemon, and parsley. What makes it different is that it’s not a pan sauce you simmer—it's a chilled finishing butter you slice and melt directly over hot steak (or fish and vegetables) for instant flavor. It’s perfect when you want a restaurant-style finish in seconds without extra cleanup.

Discover this recipe

Warm sauces for steak

Creamy Dijon

Dijon mustard sharpens a base of cream and stock. This version uses the browned bits left after cooking steak, making it especially useful for a skillet dinner.

3

Creamy Dijon Sauce for Steak

A good Dijon sauce is one of those recipes that feels more impressive than it is difficult. It is a warm, creamy pan sauce built from shallots, stock, cream, and Dijon mustard, with enough sharpness to cut through a rich steak while still feeling smooth and elegant. This version is especially useful when you want a steakhouse-style finish at home for a weekend dinner, a date night, or even a solid weeknight meal with mashed potatoes and a green vegetable.

Discover this recipe

Cognac mushroom

Browned mushrooms make this a substantial topping rather than a smooth sauce alone. Let their moisture evaporate before adding Cognac and cream.

4

Cognac Mushroom Sauce for Steak

This Cognac mushroom sauce is a rich pan sauce with browned mushrooms, shallot, reduced Cognac, beef or veal stock and cream. The sauce works because the mushrooms are cooked until their water evaporates before the alcohol and cream are added, so the finished sauce tastes concentrated rather than watery.

Discover this recipe

Red wine reduction

Reduce the wine first, then add stock and finish with cold butter for a glossy texture. This is a useful choice when you want concentrated flavor without cream.

5

Easy Red Wine Reduction Sauce for Steak

This red wine reduction sauce is a simple way to turn red wine, beef stock, shallot, and butter into a glossy, concentrated sauce for steak, beef tenderloin, pork, or roasted meats. I make it by reducing the wine first so the finished sauce tastes deep and savoury rather than sharp or alcoholic, and the main mistake to avoid is rushing that reduction. By the time the stock goes in, the wine should look darker, smell mellow, and leave only a thin syrupy layer across the bottom of the pan.

Discover this recipe

Roquefort

Roquefort gives this sauce the boldest cheese flavor in the selection. Pair it with simply prepared sides when you want that flavor to stand out.

6

Creamy Roquefort Sauce Recipe for Steak, Chicken, or Pasta

Few sauces feel as indulgent and flavorful as a creamy Roquefort sauce. Whether draped over a perfectly cooked steak, spooned onto grilled chicken breasts, or folded into hot pasta, this French blue cheese sauce adds elegance and depth with minimal effort.

Discover this recipe

Sauce Diane

Choose Diane to combine mushrooms and mustard in one pan sauce. Allow for the successive reductions and make it after cooking the steak.

7

Sauce Diane Recipe (Creamy Steakhouse Mushroom Sauce)

If you want a rich, classic pan sauce that makes steak feel instantly more special, Sauce Diane is one of the best to know. It is a creamy mushroom and shallot sauce built with cognac, mustard, stock, and cream, and it is especially good when made in the same pan as the steak so it captures all the browned flavor left behind.

Discover this recipe

Sauce Choron

This gives a different texture from a cream sauce. It needs a carefully managed warm emulsion, so keep the full recipe handy and make it close to serving time.

8

Sauce Choron (Tomato Béarnaise) — The Velvety Steakhouse Sauce You Can Make at Home

Sauce Choron is a warm, butter-emulsified sauce made from egg yolks (a sabayon base), finished with tomato for a subtle tang and a gorgeous rosy color. It’s different from classic béarnaise because it’s lighter on herbs and brighter thanks to the tomato, making it perfect when you want a steakhouse-style sauce without going full peppercorn or heavy cream. Make it when you’re cooking steak, roast beef, or even grilled vegetables and you want something rich, silky, and special.

Discover this recipe

An uncooked herb sauce

Chimichurri

For an option without butter or cream, choose these chopped herbs. This version uses lemon; adjust the chili to taste and keep the texture slightly coarse.

9

Homemade Chimichurri Recipe (Argentine Steak Sauce)

If you’ve ever enjoyed grilled steak at an Argentine asado or tried a juicy steak sandwich, you’ve probably tasted the magic of chimichurri. This fresh green sauce is bold, tangy, garlicky, and herb-packed—perfect for grilled meats, roasted vegetables, or even drizzling over chicken and fish.

Discover this recipe

Match the sauce to the meat and sides

For a delicately flavored beef tenderloin, try red wine reduction or a little maître d’hôtel butter. For a grilled steak with a more pronounced seared flavor, Montreal butter is another direction. If you enjoy blue cheese, Roquefort offers a stronger finish; start with a small amount and let guests add more.

Mashed potatoes work well with creamy sauces. With a mushroom topping, simply cooked vegetables add another texture. If the sides are already rich, lemon and parsley bring a different aromatic direction, although herb butter remains a rich finishing ingredient.

Plan the cooking order

• Prepare compound butters early enough to chill and slice.
• Allow time for the red wine reductions; excessive heat is not a substitute for reducing the sauce properly.
• For Dijon sauce, keep the skillet and browned bits after cooking the meat.
• Use gentle heat for cream and cheese sauces, and taste before salting.

Common questions

Does compound butter count as a sauce?

It starts as flavored butter. On hot meat it melts and coats the surface, providing a sauce-like finish without a last-minute reduction.

Which options use no cream?

Chimichurri uses neither cream nor butter. Choron, red wine reduction and both compound butters use no cream, but contain butter. Check each full ingredient list if you need to avoid dairy.

Do all steak sauces need pan drippings?

No. The Dijon recipe uses the steak’s browned bits, but compound butters are prepared separately. Roquefort sauce can also be made in a saucepan.

Plan the rest of the meal

Choose a cooking method from our steak recipes for the pan, oven and BBQ. For sauces beyond steak dinners, explore our homemade sauces and condiments.