Leftover Turkey à la King on Toast with Mushrooms and Peas
Turkey à la King turns a few pieces of cooked turkey into a skillet supper with mushrooms, sweet pepper and peas in a light, savoury white sauce. Spoon it onto toast just before it goes to the table. I brown the mushrooms before adding any liquid and warm the turkey at the end. Those two small decisions give the sauce some depth and keep the meat tender enough to eat with a fork. Four slices make four lunch portions, one toast each, or two generous portions of two toasts each.

Choose the pieces that suit the pan
When you carve a roast turkey with bread stuffing, the breast usually gives you clean slices. Down around the thighs and wings, the pieces come away in all sorts of shapes. Both cuts work here. Remove the skin, bones and any tough tendons, then pull the meat apart into pieces you could balance comfortably on a teaspoon. Cut long strands across the grain. You want a bite of turkey on the toast without having to chase an entire strip off the plate.
Set aside about twelve ounces for four portions. The thin, slightly dry end of a breast benefits from the sauce, but paper-thin slices fall apart if they spend too long on the stove. Fold these in with a spatula. If you have mostly bones with a few scraps attached, make turkey noodle soup instead. This skillet works best when there are enough actual pieces of meat for each person to find several on the fork.
Brown the mushrooms first
Wipe the mushrooms and trim the dry stem ends. Cut small ones in halves or thirds and slice bigger caps a little thicker than a coin. The point is to have a cut surface that makes good contact with the skillet. A mound of very thin slices turns limp almost as soon as it hits the heat. Keep the pepper separate and cut it into small dice while the mushrooms cook.
Melt the butter in a wide skillet over medium-high heat. Once it foams, spread out the mushrooms and let the first side take on some colour before stirring. At first you may hear a lively sizzle, followed by a quieter bubbling as water comes out. Let that water cook away. When the sizzle returns, look under a slice for an amber patch. That patch goes a long way toward seasoning a sauce made with fairly mild milk and broth. It is the same reason mushrooms taste fuller in a mushroom stroganoff after a little time in the pan.

Add the red pepper and cook until the edges soften, about three minutes. It should still be red and hold its shape. Putting it in with wet mushrooms slows the browning and tends to leave you with very soft pepper by the time the pan is dry enough for the flour.
Make the sauce where the flavour is
Turn the heat down to medium. Sprinkle the flour over the vegetables and stir for about a minute. It should disappear into the butter and form a light coating around the mushrooms. Run the spatula along the bottom, including the corners. If there is a little brown film left by the mushrooms, leave it in place for the broth. If a spot smells burnt, transfer the vegetables to a clean skillet before continuing.
Pour in a little broth and stir until the flour loosens into a smooth paste. Add the rest in several pours, scraping the pan as you go. Stir in the milk and bring the mixture to a gentle simmer. The idea is related to a basic béchamel, but the broth and browned mushrooms give this sauce its own flavour. Watch the spoon: the sauce should coat its back, then slide off in a broad ribbon when tilted. If it stands in a heap, loosen it with another spoonful of broth.
Stir in the peas and cooked turkey. Frozen peas can go straight in. Bring the filling to 165°F throughout, checking a bigger piece of turkey in the middle of the pan. Taste for salt after the meat goes in because roast turkey and boxed broth can both be seasoned. Take the skillet off the heat as soon as everything is hot. The meat has already had its long roast.

Toast and serve
Cut four ordinary slices of country bread, about half an inch thick. Toast both faces until the surface is dry and golden. If the toast is done early, stand the slices against one another for a minute so steam can escape. Put one on each plate and spoon some filling over the centre, leaving a corner of crust showing. Offer the rest from the pan. A modest first helping keeps the bread crisp long enough to cut into it.
For a dinner with company, the puff pastry shells used for chicken vol-au-vent are another way to serve a thick, hot filling. On a weeknight, toast gets supper on the table with one skillet to wash. If you actually want a baked crust over the turkey, follow the method for turkey pot pie.
Make ahead and substitutions

Prepare the mushroom and pepper sauce a day ahead and refrigerate it promptly in a shallow container. Keep the turkey separate. As the sauce reheats, stir in a splash of broth until the spoon moves easily through it again. Then add the meat and peas and heat through. Count storage time from when the turkey was originally cooked. Making a new sauce does not give the meat a new starting date.
Cooked chicken works ounce for ounce. A yellow or orange bell pepper gives much the same sweetness as red. For a softer filling on toast, use leftover white sandwich bread; for a sturdier base, choose a close-crumbed country loaf. Avoid bread with big holes down the centre because the first spoonful goes straight through. If you prefer noodles to toast, turkey tetrazzini has a sauce proportion worked out for pasta.
Questions from the kitchen
Why did the sauce thin out after I added the vegetables?
Water left in the mushrooms is often responsible. Let their cooking liquid evaporate before adding flour. Frozen peas may cool the pan briefly; wait for a gentle simmer before deciding whether the sauce needs adjustment. If it is genuinely thin, lift out the turkey and reduce the sauce for a minute or two so the meat stays tender.
Can I serve it with potatoes?
Yes. A split baked potato catches the sauce, especially when you fluff the inside with a fork first. If you have enough leftover mash to cover a family-sized dish, turkey shepherd’s pie makes better use of it. The leftover turkey collection also has options for the smaller pieces left after carving.
What goes alongside the toast?
Choose something with a little acidity or crunch. A spoonful of green bean salad with raspberry vinaigrette cuts through the milk sauce. For a hot plate, maple-glazed carrots can cook while the mushrooms brown. Serve either on the clear part of the plate so its dressing stays off the toast.
Serving suggestions and related recipes
Put the green bean salad with raspberry vinaigrette in a separate bowl so the dressing stays away from the toast. For a warm vegetable, maple-glazed carrots can share the plate with the turkey.

Leftover Turkey à la King on Toast with Mushrooms and Peas
Ingredients
- 12 ounces cooked turkey cut into bite-sized pieces
- 6½ ounces mushrooms sliced
- 1 red bell pepper seeded and finely diced
- 2½ tablespoons unsalted butter
- ¼ cup all-purpose flour
- 1 cup low-sodium chicken broth plus more as needed
- ¾ cup milk
- ½ cup frozen green peas
- 4 slices country bread about ½ inch thick
- Salt and black pepper to taste
Instructions
- Melt butter in a wide skillet over medium-high heat. Brown mushrooms for about 5 minutes, letting their liquid evaporate.
- Add pepper and cook 3 minutes. Lower heat to medium, stir in flour and cook 1 minute.

- Gradually stir in broth, then milk. Simmer gently until the sauce coats a spoon.
- Fold in turkey and peas. Heat throughout to 165°F. Season and add a spoonful of broth if the sauce is too thick.

- Toast bread on both sides. Spoon the hot filling over the toast immediately before serving.






Last chance for our paring knives.