Leftover Turkey and Wild Rice Casserole with Mushrooms
This turkey and wild rice casserole puts cooked turkey and cooked rice in a mushroom and leek sauce, with a little cheddar browned on top. I make the sauce in the same pan as the mushrooms so their browned juices season the whole dish. It serves six and works particularly well with the smaller pieces left after carving a roast.

Measure the rice after cooking
The quantity in the card is cooked, drained rice. If you start with dry grains, cook your wild rice blend separately according to its package, then drain and measure what goes into the casserole. Different blends contain different proportions of wild rice, brown rice and long-grain white rice. Their cooking times and yields vary. Bite one of the darkest grains. It can have a pleasant chew, but there should be no hard point in the centre. The short bake in cream sauce will not finish a batch of raw rice.
Fluff the cooked grains with a fork before combining them with the sauce. Rice packed tightly in a refrigerator container can come out in one solid block. Loosen it gently while it is still by itself. Trying to break that block up in the finished casserole can tear the turkey into threads and crush the mushrooms. A leftover batch of plain rice pilaf can also be used by cooked weight, though the finished dish will have a softer bite and a paler colour.
Cut the turkey across the grain
Use a mix of breast and dark meat if you have it. Pull away any pieces of skin, cartilage or small bone left from carving. Cut breast meat across the long fibres into bite-size pieces. Leave tender thigh meat in somewhat larger chunks so it remains identifiable once the rice is stirred in. A well-seasoned roast turkey with bacon stuffing brings plenty of flavour of its own. Taste a piece of the cooked meat before seasoning the sauce, particularly if the bird was brined.
If your leftovers include the carcass, reserve it for turkey noodle soup. The casserole uses the meat you can lift cleanly from the bones. Keep a few broad slices aside for turkey cranberry sliders if you plan a second meal. A casserole is an especially good use for oddly shaped pieces because you can cut them to a uniform bite without sacrificing the appearance of a platter of carved turkey.
Brown the mushrooms and build the sauce
Split the leek lengthwise and rinse between its layers, especially where the white turns pale green. Drain it, slice thinly and set aside. Slice the mushrooms a little thicker so they keep some texture. Melt the butter in a wide pan over medium-high heat. Add the mushrooms and let them release their water. At first the pan may sound like a pot of boiling water. Keep cooking until the sound turns to a sizzle and the underside of a mushroom shows a brown patch. Only then add the leek.

Cook the leek for about four minutes until it bends readily around the spoon. Sprinkle flour over the vegetables and stir to coat. Pour in a small splash of broth first, scraping the base and smoothing the flour. Add the remaining broth gradually, then the cream. Simmer for three minutes while stirring around the edge of the pan. The principle is close to making a roux-based white sauce, except that the vegetables are already in the pan. If using chicken stock concentrate, dilute it before measuring the broth.
Bake until the middle is hot
Fold the rice and turkey into the sauce. Lift from the bottom with a broad spoon and stop once everything has a light coating. At this stage the mixture should settle back into the hollow left by a spoon. If it stands in a dry mound, loosen it with a splash of broth. If there is a deep pool of sauce at one edge, first check for a clump of rice you have missed. Taste for salt and pepper, then transfer to a shallow two-quart baking dish. Spread the grated cheddar lightly over the top.

Bake at 375°F for twenty-five to thirty-five minutes. The edge usually bubbles first. Check the middle with a thermometer and serve when it reaches 165°F. If the cheese colours early, cover loosely while the centre finishes. The turkey was already cooked, so take the dish out once it is hot throughout. A longer bake does not make the breast meat more tender. Let it stand briefly while you bring a green bean salad to the table, then serve with a spoon that reaches the full depth of the dish.
Make ahead and substitutions

If making the components in advance, cool the cooked rice promptly in a shallow container and refrigerate it. Keep the turkey chilled too. You can combine cold components with chilled sauce and refrigerate the assembled dish for a later meal, taking the original storage time of the turkey and rice into account. Allow extra baking time from cold and rely on the centre temperature. For a different make-ahead dish using mashed potatoes instead of grains, turkey shepherd’s pie makes good use of the same roast.
Cooked chicken can replace turkey in the same amount. Cremini and white button mushrooms both work; with either one, wait for the water to evaporate before adding the leek. If you have no leek, a finely chopped onion softened until tender will give a slightly sweeter base. Keep any cranberry sauce on the side. Its acidity is pleasant with a rich forkful, but stirring it into the cream would change the flavour and colour of the whole dish.

Questions about the rice and leftovers
Why did the filling turn watery?
Check the mushrooms, the drained rice and the sauce separately. Mushrooms added to the sauce while still swimming in their own juice bring extra liquid. Wet rice does the same. Give the flour-thickened sauce its full simmer before adding either rice or meat. If the casserole is already baked, let it settle for a few minutes. An extra half hour in the oven can dry the turkey before it solves the watery sauce.
Can I make a smaller dish?
Halve all the ingredients and use a dish that gives a similar depth of filling. Start checking earlier because the centre of a smaller casserole can warm more quickly. For a very small amount of turkey, these other leftover turkey recipes give you options for dividing the meat among smaller meals. Weighing the meat before you choose the pan makes the decision much easier.
Serving suggestions and related recipes
Offer cranberry sauce in a small dish so each person can add a tart bite between forkfuls of rice. A chilled green bean salad brings a useful crunch to a soft, hot casserole.

Leftover Turkey and Wild Rice Casserole with Mushrooms
Ingredients
- 12 oz cooked turkey diced
- 1 lb cooked drained wild rice blend
- 7 oz mushrooms sliced
- 1 leek white and pale green parts, rinsed and sliced
- 2½ tbsp unsalted butter
- ¼ cup all-purpose flour
- 1¼ cups low-sodium turkey or chicken broth
- ⅝ cup cream
- 1¾ oz cheddar grated
- Salt and black pepper to taste
Instructions
- Heat oven to 375°F. Brown mushrooms in butter over medium-high heat until their water evaporates. Add leek and soften 4 minutes.

- Stir in flour, gradually add broth and cream and simmer 3 minutes, stirring.
- Fold in cooked rice and diced turkey. Season and transfer to a shallow 2-quart dish. Scatter cheddar over top.
- Bake 25 to 35 minutes until bubbling and 165°F at the centre. For a refrigerated casserole, check the centre and continue baking until it reaches 165°F. Cover if the cheese is already brown.







Last chance for our paring knives.