|

Double Grilled Cheese with Three Cheeses and Ham

This double grilled cheese is a big, rich, three-layer sandwich made with brioche bread, cheddar, Swiss cheese, blue cheese, and ham. It is based on my YouTube video, with a few adjustments since publication so the recipe works better in a regular home kitchen.

The idea is simple: instead of only putting shredded cheese between two slices of bread, I melt the cheddar and Swiss gently, chill it into a thin sliceable layer, then build the sandwich with toasted brioche, ham, and small pieces of blue cheese. The mistake to avoid is making the cheese layer too thick. If it is too heavy, the outside gets hot before the center has time to soften.

What Makes This Recipe Different

This is not the classic thin grilled cheese you make in a pan with two slices of bread and a little cheddar. This one is more like a restaurant-style sandwich: three slices of bread, two cheese layers, ham in the middle, and a quick finish under the broiler.

I make it this way because melting the cheddar and Swiss first gives you a generous, even layer of cheese. It also lets you cut the cheese to the size of the bread, which makes the final sandwich cleaner and easier to stack. In the video, I use the fat that separates from the cheese to brush the bread. At home, you can do that, or you can use melted butter.

The result is different from my pizza-style grilled cheese because this version is not about tomato sauce, pepperoni, or pizza flavor. It is more direct: bread, cheese, ham, heat, and texture. It is also more cheese-focused than a classic tuna melt or a hot deli sandwich like my Quebec-style Reuben.

Ingredients You Need

You need only a few ingredients, but the proportions matter. For one large triple-decker sandwich, I prefer about 3 ounces of cheddar, 2 ounces of Swiss cheese, and less than 1 ounce of blue cheese. That gives you a strong cheese flavor without turning the sandwich into a salty block.

Brioche bread works very well here because it browns quickly and stays soft inside. The sugar in the bread gives a nice color under the broiler, but it also means you need to watch it closely. It can go from golden to burned very fast.

For the ham, use thinly sliced deli ham or good butcher ham. You do not need too much. About 2 ounces is enough because the cheese is already rich. If you want a more sandwich-style meal, you can add more ham, but I would not increase the cheese at the same time.

Blue cheese should be used carefully. I like small pieces scattered through the middle layer, not a full thick layer. You want little salty, creamy pockets, not one strong bite that takes over the whole sandwich.

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, step 1

Step-by-Step Instructions

Start by shredding the cheddar and Swiss cheese. Shredded cheese melts more evenly than large pieces. If you are using a box grater, use the larger holes. If the cheese is too finely grated, it can clump and become oily faster.

Place the cheddar and Swiss in a small saucepan over very low heat. Stir slowly and constantly. What I look for here is not a bubbling cheese sauce. I want the cheese to soften into a thick paste. If a little fat separates, that is okay. Keep it. That fat is excellent for brushing the bread before the final broil.

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, step 2

Once the cheese has melted into a rough, thick mass, transfer it to a small dish or plate lined with parchment paper. Press it into a thin, even layer. It should be about the same thickness as a generous slice of cheese, not a thick block. Chill it for 10 to 15 minutes, just until firm enough to cut.

While the cheese cools, preheat your oven broiler. Place the oven rack about 4 to 6 inches from the heat source. This is important because broilers are not all the same. In the video, the bread colors in seconds, but in a home oven it may take 30 seconds to 2 minutes. Watch it the whole time.

Place the three slices of brioche on a baking sheet and broil until lightly golden. Flip and toast the second side. You know the bread is ready when it has color but still bends slightly. If it becomes too dry at this stage, the final sandwich will be harder to press and cut.

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, step 3

Take the chilled cheese layer out of the fridge and cut it into pieces that fit the bread. Brush the toasted bread with the reserved cheese fat or melted butter. This gives the sandwich that grilled-cheese richness, even though we are finishing it under the broiler instead of in a pan.

Place cheese pieces on two slices of toast. Broil again until the cheese softens and starts to look glossy. Do not walk away. The goal is melted and hot, not browned hard.

Add the ham to one of the cheese-topped slices. Scatter the blue cheese over the ham in small pieces. Return that slice under the broiler briefly, just until the blue cheese softens and the ham is warm.

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, step 4

Now stack the sandwich. Put one cheese layer on the bottom, the ham and blue cheese layer in the middle, and the final slice of toast on top. Press lightly with your hand or a spatula. The sandwich should compress a little but not collapse.

Return the assembled sandwich to the warm oven for 1 to 2 minutes, or place it back under the broiler for a few seconds if it needs more heat. I prefer a gentle final warm-up because the sandwich is already toasted. At this point, you are not trying to cook it. You are just making sure the center is hot.

Cut the sandwich in half and serve right away. The inside should look soft, glossy, and melted, with the blue cheese visible in small pockets.

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, finished dish

Tips for Better Results

The main thing is heat control. High heat is useful for browning bread, but it can also ruin the sandwich quickly. Keep the cheese melting step gentle, then use the broiler only in short bursts.

The cheese slab should be thin. If you spread it too thick, it will cool into a heavy block and take too long to warm through. A thinner layer gives a better bite and melts again more easily.

Do not overdo the blue cheese. A little gives character. Too much makes the sandwich salty and sharp. This is especially true because ham, cheddar, Swiss, and blue cheese all bring salt.

If your cheese splits a little in the saucepan, do not panic. A small amount of separated fat is normal when cheese is melted directly. Use it to brush the bread. If the cheese becomes grainy, the heat was probably too high.

This is a rich comfort-food sandwich, not a light lunch. I usually serve half with something fresh and crunchy, like a romaine and endive green salad or a simple cabbage salad. It balances the salt and fat much better than adding more heavy sides.

What to Serve With It

Because this sandwich is very rich, I like sides with crunch, acid, or potatoes.

For a classic diner-style plate, serve it with crispy panko onion rings or beer batter onion rings. If you want something cold on the side, a creamy dill pickle potato salad works well because the pickles cut through the cheese.

For a bigger comfort-food meal, it also pairs with crispy homemade hash browns or potato and cheese pierogi, but I would keep the portion small. This sandwich already has plenty of cheese.

If you want more sandwich ideas, try the garlic butter steak sandwich, the fast smash breakfast sandwich, the Montreal club sandwich, or the Monte Cristo sandwich. They are all in the same comfort-food family, but each one has a different purpose.

Substitutions

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, finished dish

You can replace brioche with white sandwich bread, sourdough, or Texas toast. Brioche gives the softest result, while sourdough gives more chew and a slightly sharper flavor.

For the cheese, cheddar and Swiss are a good base because cheddar brings strength and Swiss melts smoothly. Monterey Jack, mozzarella, provolone, or Gouda can replace the Swiss if you want a milder melt. If you want to make your own cheese component from scratch, my homemade fresh cheese is a good related recipe, but for this sandwich I still prefer melting cheeses like cheddar and Swiss.

If you do not like blue cheese, leave it out or replace it with a little goat cheese. Do not use too much. You only need a few small pieces to add contrast.

The ham can be replaced with turkey, cooked bacon, roast beef, or left out for a vegetarian version. For another cheese-forward vegetarian idea, the cheese quesadillas cooked in a pan are simpler and faster.

You can also skip the melted-and-chilled cheese slab method. For the easiest version, layer shredded cheddar and Swiss directly onto the toasted bread, broil until melted, then assemble with ham and blue cheese. The texture will be less structured, but it is more beginner-friendly.

double grilled cheese three cheeses ham, finished dish

FAQ

Can I make this in a skillet instead of the oven?

Yes. Toast the bread first, then assemble the sandwich and warm it in a covered skillet over low heat. The lid helps trap heat so the cheese melts without burning the bread.

Why melt and chill the cheese first?

It creates a thick, even cheese layer that can be cut to the size of the bread. I make it this way because it gives the sandwich a more controlled, restaurant-style structure. For a quick home version, shredded cheese directly on the bread also works.

What is the biggest mistake to avoid?

The biggest mistake is using too much cheese or making the cheese slab too thick. The sandwich will look impressive, but the middle may stay firm while the bread gets too dark.

Can I make it ahead?

Not really. You can prepare the cheese layer ahead and keep it chilled, but the sandwich should be assembled and heated right before serving. Grilled cheese is best when the bread is hot and the cheese is soft.

Is blue cheese necessary?

No. It adds a strong, salty flavor, but the sandwich still works with only cheddar, Swiss, and ham. If you are serving people who do not like blue cheese, use less or leave it out.

What bread works best?

Brioche is excellent because it browns quickly and stays soft. Sourdough is also good, but it gives a firmer bite. Regular white bread works, but choose thick slices so the sandwich holds together.

Double Grilled Cheese with Three Cheeses and Ham

Chef Dumas
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cooking Time 8 minutes
Total Time 23 minutes
Category Sandwiches
Cuisine American
Portions 2
Calories 565 kcal

Ingredients
  

  • 3 slices brioche bread
  • 3 oz cheddar cheese shredded
  • 2 oz Swiss cheese shredded
  • 3/4 oz blue cheese cut into small pieces
  • 2 oz thinly sliced ham
  • 1 tbsp melted butter or reserved cheese fat

Instructions
 

  • Shred the cheddar and Swiss cheese.
  • Place the cheddar and Swiss in a small saucepan over very low heat.
  • Stir gently until the cheese melts into a thick paste, keeping any separated fat.
  • Spread the melted cheese into a thin layer on parchment paper and chill for 10 to 15 minutes.
  • Preheat the broiler and place the oven rack 4 to 6 inches from the heat.
  • Toast the brioche slices under the broiler on both sides, watching constantly.
  • Brush the toast with reserved cheese fat or melted butter.
  • Cut the chilled cheese layer to fit the bread and place it on 2 slices of toast.
  • Broil briefly until the cheese softens and looks glossy.
  • Add the ham and blue cheese to one cheese-topped slice.
  • Broil again briefly until the ham is warm and the blue cheese softens.
  • Stack the sandwich into 3 layers, press lightly, and warm for 1 to 2 minutes.
  • Cut in half and serve hot.

Notes

Watch the broiler constantly. For an easier version, skip the chilled cheese slab and melt shredded cheese directly on the toasted bread.
Keywords Cheese, Grilled Cheese, Sandwich

Articles similaires

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *